Yamaha Road Star S vs Harley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom (2016)

Side-by-side spec comparison, pricing, and a plain-English breakdown of how the Yamaha Road Star Sstacks up against the Harley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom. Numbers pulled from manufacturer spec sheets — click either bike for the full review.

Spec comparison

SpecYamaha Road Star SHarley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom
Model year20162013
Price$12,990$15,599
Engine1674 cc1688 cc
Torque134 Nm
Weight294 kg
Seat height28 mm24 mm
Fuel capacity4.8 L5.0 L
Fuel typepetrolpetrol
Transmission5-speed6-speed
Front brakesDouble disc. Hydraulic. Single disc
Rear brakesSingle disc. Hydraulic. Single disc
Tires130/90-M16 / 150/80-B16 MH90-21 / 200/55-R17

Yamaha Road Star S vs Harley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom — which should you buy?

Picking between the Yamaha Road Star S and the Harley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom usually comes down to the numbers you care about most. On paper, the Yamaha Road Star S brings its published horsepower, while the Harley-Davidson Softail Blackline Dark Custom counters with its own power figure at 294 kg. On price, the Yamaha Road Star S has the lower MSRP.

Our spec tables above highlight the winning number on each line. For the full rider-focused reviews including real-world fuel economy, service costs and available colors, click into either bike: